|
Selected Annotated Bibliography on Performance of Officers with
Bachelor’s Degrees
reprinted from "College
Education and Policing" By Louis Mayo, Ph.D., Executive
Director, Police Association for College Education, in the August
2006 edition of Police Chief magazine.
Aamodt, Michael G. Research in Law Enforcement
Selection. Boca Raton, Florida: Brown Walker Press, 2004.
Summarizes 330 studies investigating the
validity of methods used to select law enforcement personnel.
Concludes that officers with a college education perform better in
the academy, receive higher performance ratings on the job, have
fewer disciplinary problems, have less absenteeism, and use force
less often than their peers without a college education.
American Bar Association. The Urban Police
Function. By Herman Goldstein and Sheldon Krantz. Chicago, 1973.
Police need personnel in their ranks
who have the characteristics a college education seeks to foster;
intellectual curiosity, analytical ability, articulateness, and a
capacity to relate the events of the day to the social, political,
and historical context in which they occur.
U.S. National Institute of Mental Health. The
Functions of the Police in a Modern Society: A Review of Background
Factors, Current Practices, and Possible Role Models. By Egon
Bittner. Rockville, Maryland: 1972.
Recommends a goal of a master’s degree for entering officers.
Carter, David L., Darrel W. Stephens, and Al D.
Sapp. "Effect of Higher Education on Police Liability: Implications
for Police Personnel Policy." American Journal of Police 8
(1989): 153–166. Officers with
college degrees are less likely than officers with less education to
incur citizen complaints. Higher officer education reduces liability
risks for police departments.
Cohen, Bernard, and Jan M. Chaiken. Police
Background Characteristics and Performances: Summary. New York:
Rand, 1972. Study of 1,600 New York
City police officers found that when education is introduced into
the regression equation for civilian complaints, it emerged as the
most powerful predictor of civilian complaints.
Committee on Integrity. Report to Mayor Daly.
Chicago, Illinois: 1997.
Recommends bachelor’s degrees for officers to reduce corruption. The
same recommendation was made for the same reason by the Royal
Commission into the New South Wales Police Service (Final Report:
Volume 1: Corruption, 1997).
Cunningham, Scott. "Discipline and Educational
Levels of Law Enforcement Officers, an Exploratory Report." Paper
presented at the 110th Annual IACP Conference, Philadelphia,
Pennsylvania, 2003. Statewide study in Florida found that
officers with only high school diplomas accounted for a
disproportionately high number of discipline cases.
Davis v. Dallas, 777 F.2d 205 (5th
Cir. 1985). The need for police
officers who are intelligent, articulate, mature, and knowledgeable
about social and political conditions is apparent. . . . [A] college
education develops and imparts the requisite level of knowledge.
Finckenauer, J. O. "Higher Education and Police
Discretion." Journal of Police Science and Administration 3
(December 1975). A series of
vignettes illustrating different police discretionary situations
were presented to police recruits, comparing responses from
college-educated and non-college-educated recruits. College-educated
recruits were more likely to choose approaches not involving an
arrest or other official action.
Fullerton, Ernie. "Higher Education as a
Prerequisite to Employment as a Law Enforcement Officer."
Dissertation, University of Pittsburgh, 2002.
Summarizes the works of ten researchers from 1967 to 1992 who found
important desirable traits for officers that are achieved through
college education: less cynicism, less authoritarianism, less
attrition, fewer disciplinary problems, more local pride in the
police department, fewer sick days, higher academic performance,
more awards, higher felony arrests made, higher performance
evaluations, better decision making, flexibility in problem solving,
greater empathy toward minorities, less negativity toward legal
restrictions, more discretion and less control-oriented, less
inclined toward rigid enforcement of the law, and less support for
insularity.
Kappaler, V. E., Allen D. Sapp, and David L.
Carter. "Police Officer Higher Education, Citizen Complaints, and
Departmental Rule Violations." American Journal of Police 11
(February 1992): 35–54. This is a
study of a midsize Midwestern police department for relationship
between college graduate officers and complaints. Officers with
college degrees had statistically significant fewer complaints than
officers without college degrees.
President’s Commission on Law Enforcement and the
Administration of Justice. Task Force Report: The Police.
Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1967.
It is nonsense to state or assume that the enforcement of the law is
so simple that it can be done best by those unencumbered by the
study of liberal arts. . . . Police agencies need personnel in their
ranks who have the characteristics which a college education seeks
to foster: . . . a capacity to relate the events of the day to the
social, political, and historical context in which they occur.
Sanderson, B. E. "Police Officers: The
Relationship of College Education to Job Performance." The Police
Chief 44 (August 1977): 62–63.
College education is positively related to numerous performance
indicators, including academy performance, discipline, absenteeism,
terminations, and career advancement.
Tyre, Mitchell, and Susan Braunstein. "Higher
Education and Ethical Policing." FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin
61 (June 1992): 6–10. Specific
studies indicate that better educated officers choose more ethical
actions.
Wilson, Hugh. "Post-secondary Education of the
Police Officer and Its Effect on the Frequency of Citizens’
Complaints." Journal of California Law Enforcement 33 (April
1999). Study of several California
police departments found that officers with bachelor’s degrees
receive fewer complaints than officers with no degrees. v
|